Heil Hedlyn, eh?
Most of what's being said doesn't acctually contradict. The basic underlying point is that; yes, the roleplaying community can do something - but it needs activity first and foremost. The only point of contention is where that activity should be focused. I'm afraid I personally I agree that Magincia seems a waste of time and effort. It's room for roleplay, yes, but not in it's current state. As it stands it's just
another scripted invasion, for the PVM maistream. Though RP can involve itself there, it can't
really be focused on it. Afterwards, whatever the outcome, then perhaps it might. But for the time being Magincia should be considered a glorified Dungeon. That isn't to say that it's entirely worthless heading there, however. All it really needs is for more people to get involved, and turn it into an RP hotspot, which at the moment it's simply the
essence of.